Vertex Learn

Level 1 Science claims practice paper 2026

Question One

Question One

Resource A: NightOwl Optics website (product page)

SLEEP BETTER TONIGHT with NightOwl Blue-Block Glasses.

Phones and laptops give off blue light, which tells your brain it is still daytime. Our patented amber lenses block 99% of blue light, so your body can make melatonin, the sleep hormone, naturally.

Clinically tested: in our 2025 trial, 20 NightOwl customers wore the glasses for two hours before bed for one week. On average they fell asleep in 31 minutes, compared with 37 minutes the week before.

"I fall asleep so much faster now!" Aroha, Hamilton

$89 with free shipping anywhere in New Zealand.

2830323436383731Week beforeWith NightOwlMinutes to fall asleep
a
Achieved

Use Resource A.

(i) Who published this information?

(ii) Why was this information published?

(iii) What is a science-related claim in this resource?

Hint

The publisher is whoever owns the page, not the person in the quote. For the purpose, look for a price. A claim is something testable that they want you to believe.

Answer

(i) NightOwl Optics, the company that makes and sells the glasses, on its own website. (ii) To persuade people to buy NightOwl glasses; it also informs readers about blue light, but the price and free shipping show its main purpose is to sell. (iii) Wearing NightOwl glasses for two hours before bed helps you fall asleep faster.

Step by step
  1. (i) Look at whose page it is: NightOwl Optics, the company selling the glasses.
  2. (ii) The price ($89) and free shipping show the purpose is to sell. Informing about blue light is a second purpose.
  3. (iii) A science-related claim is a testable conclusion backed by evidence: the glasses help you fall asleep faster.
  4. Another acceptable claim: the lenses block 99% of blue light.
Full working
  1. (i) NightOwl Optics, the company that sells the glassespublisher
  2. (ii) to persuade people to buy them ($89, free shipping)purpose
  3. (iii) wearing the glasses before bed helps you fall asleep fasterclaim
b
Merit

What science language or conventions are used to support the claim you gave in (a)(iii)? Explain how each one is used to make the claim more believable.

Hint

Science language: which technical words appear? Conventions: is there a trial, numbers with units, a graph? For each, say what it makes a reader think.

Answer

Science language: blue light, melatonin, the sleep hormone, patented and clinically tested. Words like melatonin link the claim to real body chemistry many readers have heard of, so it sounds like it is based on science, and clinically tested suggests a proper trial was done. Conventions: a trial with a number of people (20 customers), average times with units (31 minutes compared with 37 minutes), and a bar graph. Giving numbers with units makes the result look precise and measured. The bar graph makes the improvement look large, because its axis starts at 28 minutes: the before bar is drawn three times as tall as the after bar, even though the real difference is 6 minutes, about 16%.

Step by step
  1. List the science language: blue light, melatonin, sleep hormone, patented, clinically tested.
  2. Explain the effect: these words make the claim sound scientific, and clinically tested suggests a proper trial.
  3. List the conventions: a trial (20 people), averages with units (31 and 37 minutes), a bar graph.
  4. Explain the effect: numbers with units look precise and measured.
  5. The graph: the axis starts at 28, so the bars are 37 − 28 = 9 and 31 − 28 = 3 units tall. The before bar looks three times as tall.
  6. The real change: 37 − 31 = 6 minutes, and 6 ÷ 37 ≈ 16%.
Full working
  1. language: blue light, melatonin, sleep hormone, clinically testedsounds scientific
  2. conventions: trial of 20, averages with units (31 vs 37 minutes)looks measured
  3. bar graph axis starts at 28: bars 9 and 3 tall, three times as talllooks bigger
  4. real change 6 minutes, 6 ÷ 37 ≈ 16%the truth
c
Excellence

How well do the science language and conventions in Resource A support the claim you gave in (a)(iii)? Use evidence from the resource to support your answer.

Hint

Weigh it: what would a fair test of the glasses need? Check the sample size, whether there was a control group, who ran the trial and whether anyone checked it. Then say what would make the claim stronger.

Answer

Poorly. The language sounds scientific, but the conventions behind it are weak. The trial had only 20 people, so the 6-minute difference could be a fluke. There was no control group: people compared one week with the week before, so the change could come from expecting to sleep better (a placebo effect), from a different routine, or from chance. The 20 people were customers who had already chosen to buy the glasses, so they were likely to expect them to work. The company that sells the glasses ran its own trial, a conflict of interest, and there is no sign it was peer reviewed or published, so nobody independent has checked it. The graph's axis starts at 28 minutes, which makes a 16% change look like a threefold one. The 99% blue light figure may be true, but it does not show that blocking blue light improves sleep. To support the claim, NightOwl would need a larger trial with a control group wearing clear lenses that look the same, run or checked by independent scientists and peer reviewed.

Step by step
  1. Give a verdict first: the claim is poorly supported.
  2. Sample size: 20 people is small, so the result could be a fluke.
  3. No control group: compared with the week before, so expectation (placebo), routine or chance could explain the change.
  4. The people were customers who chose to buy the glasses, so they may expect a benefit.
  5. Who ran it: the seller, a conflict of interest, with no peer review.
  6. The graph exaggerates: a 16% change drawn as three times as big.
  7. Blocking 99% of blue light is not the same as proving better sleep.
  8. Say what would make it stronger: a large trial with a control group wearing clear lenses, run independently and peer reviewed. Weighing several points and saying what would improve the evidence is Excellence.
Full working
  1. verdict: poorly supportedweigh it
  2. only 20 people, no control group: placebo, routine or chance could explain 6 minmethod
  3. seller ran its own trial on its own customers, not peer reviewedconflict of interest
  4. axis from 28 makes 16% look threefold; 99% blue light is not better sleeppresentation
  5. stronger: large trial, clear-lens control group, independent, peer reviewedwhat would fix it
Question Two

Question Two

Resource B: news article from a university news website

Blue-light glasses probably won't help you sleep, review finds. Southern University News, 12 March 2026.

A team at the university's Southern Sleep Lab has combined the results of 14 randomised controlled trials, involving 540 adults in total, published in peer-reviewed journals between 2008 and 2025. In each trial, some people wore blue-light-filtering glasses in the evening and a control group wore glasses with clear lenses that looked the same. Nobody knew which glasses they had.

The review, now published in a peer-reviewed journal, found no clear difference between the two groups in how long people took to fall asleep or how well they slept.

"The evidence is low certainty, because most of the trials were small and lasted only a few weeks," said the lead author. "We can't rule out a small effect, but there is no good evidence that these glasses improve sleep."

The review was funded by a government health research grant. The authors declared no conflicts of interest.

a
Achieved

Use Resource B.

(i) Who published this information?

(ii) Why was this information published?

(iii) What is a science-related claim in this resource?

Hint

This time the publisher is a university. Think about who did the research and why a university tells the public about it.

Answer

(i) Southern University's news website, reporting on a review by researchers at the university's Southern Sleep Lab. (ii) To inform the public about the review's findings, and to promote the university's research. (iii) Blue-light-filtering glasses make little or no difference to how quickly people fall asleep or how well they sleep.

Step by step
  1. (i) The publisher is the university's news website; the research was done by its Southern Sleep Lab.
  2. (ii) Its purpose is mainly to inform, and also to show off the university's research.
  3. (iii) The claim: blue-light glasses probably do not improve sleep.
Full working
  1. (i) Southern University news website, about its own Sleep Lab's reviewpublisher
  2. (ii) to inform the public, and promote the university's researchpurpose
  3. (iii) blue-light glasses make little or no difference to sleepclaim
b
Merit

What science language or conventions are used to support the claim you gave in (a)(iii)? Explain how each one is used to make the claim more believable.

Hint

Look for the conventions a fair test needs: how many trials and people, a control group, peer review, and who paid.

Answer

Science language: randomised controlled trials, control group, peer-reviewed, review and low certainty. Conventions: the results of 14 trials with 540 adults were combined, which is much more evidence than one small study. Each trial had a control group wearing clear lenses that looked the same, and nobody knew which they had, so any difference would come from the filter rather than from expecting to sleep better. The trials and the review were peer reviewed, so other experts checked the methods. The funding source is named and the authors declared no conflicts of interest, so readers can see they gain nothing from either answer. The cautious wording, low certainty and we can't rule out a small effect, matches the evidence, which makes the writers more believable.

Step by step
  1. List the language: randomised controlled trial, control group, peer-reviewed, low certainty.
  2. Many trials and people (14 trials, 540 adults) give more reliable evidence than one small study.
  3. A control group with identical clear lenses means expectation cannot explain a difference.
  4. Peer review means experts checked the methods.
  5. Named funding and no conflicts of interest show the authors had no reason to favour an answer.
  6. Cautious language matches the evidence, which makes the source more trustworthy.
Full working
  1. 14 trials, 540 adults combinedmore evidence than one study
  2. control group in identical clear lenses, nobody knewrules out expectation
  3. peer reviewed trials and reviewexperts checked
  4. government funding, no conflicts; low certainty stated honestlytrustworthy
c
Excellence

How well do the science language and conventions in Resource B support its claim that blue-light glasses make little or no difference to sleep? Use evidence from the resource to support your answer.

Hint

Weigh the strengths against the limits the article itself admits. Then compare with Resource A: which claim is better supported, and why?

Answer

Well, with limits. Combining 14 randomised controlled trials with 540 adults gives far more evidence than one small trial, and because every trial had a control group wearing clear lenses that looked the same, with nobody knowing which glasses they had, a difference would show the effect of the filter rather than expectation. The trials and the review were peer reviewed, so independent experts checked the methods, and the funding is public with no declared conflicts, so the authors gain nothing from either result. However, the lead author says the evidence is low certainty because most trials were small and lasted only a few weeks, so a small effect, or an effect over months, cannot be ruled out. The cautious wording, probably and no good evidence, matches this, which makes the claim more believable rather than less. Compared with Resource A, whose 20 customers had no control group and whose trial was run by the seller, Resource B supports its claim much better, but it does not prove the glasses never help.

Step by step
  1. Verdict first: well supported, with limits.
  2. Strength: 14 trials and 540 adults, far more than 20 people.
  3. Strength: identical-looking clear lenses as a control, and nobody knew, so expectation is ruled out.
  4. Strength: peer review, public funding and no conflicts of interest.
  5. Limit: the authors admit low certainty, small and short trials, so a small or long-term effect is possible.
  6. The careful wording matches the evidence, which adds trust.
  7. Compare with Resource A to finish: B's evidence is much stronger, but it does not prove the glasses never work.
Full working
  1. verdict: well supported, with limitsweigh it
  2. 14 trials, 540 adults, identical clear-lens control, nobody knewstrong method
  3. peer reviewed, public funding, no conflictsindependent
  4. limit: low certainty, small short trials; a small effect not ruled outhonest limits
  5. far better than A's 20 customers with no control, but not proof they never helpcompare

All NCEA Level 1 Science

A Vertex Academy practice paper, written from NZQA's 2026 assessment specification for AS 91923. It is not an NZQA paper. Grades use the 2025 exam's cut scores: 3, 5 and 7 out of 8 for Achieved, Merit and Excellence.