Level 3 Biology evolution and speciation practice paper 2026
Question One
New Zealand has about 14 species of alpine buttercup (Ranunculus). DNA evidence suggests they evolved from a common ancestor in the last few million years, as the Southern Alps rose and glaciers repeatedly advanced and retreated.
Describe allopatric speciation, and name and describe two prezygotic isolating mechanisms.
Hint
Allopatric means 'other place'. Prezygotic mechanisms stop a zygote from forming.
Answer
Allopatric speciation happens when a population is split by a geographical barrier (such as a mountain range, a glacier or the sea). The separated populations stop exchanging genes (no gene flow), and they change independently through mutation, natural selection and genetic drift, until they are so different that they can no longer interbreed even if they meet again: they are separate species. Prezygotic isolating mechanisms stop mating or fertilisation. Examples: temporal isolation, where populations breed or flower at different times of year, so they cannot interbreed; habitat (ecological) isolation, where populations live in different habitats in the same area, such as different altitudes or soils, so they rarely meet. (Others: behavioural, mechanical, gametic.)
Step by step
- A geographical barrier splits a population into isolated groups.
- No gene flow between them, so their gene pools change separately (mutation, selection, drift).
- Eventually they cannot interbreed: new species.
- Temporal isolation: different breeding or flowering times.
- Habitat isolation: different habitats in the same area, so they do not meet.
- Other prezygotic barriers: behavioural, mechanical, gametic.
Full working
- geographical barrierno gene flow | gene pools diverge | new species
- prezygotic: temporal (different flowering times)
- prezygotic: habitat (different altitudes or soils)
Explain how the uplift of the Southern Alps and repeated glaciation could have led to the adaptive radiation of New Zealand alpine buttercups.
Hint
Orogeny made new habitats. Glaciers then split populations again and again.
Answer
Orogeny (mountain building) raised the Southern Alps over the last few million years, creating many new alpine habitats: scree, bogs, snowbanks, rock faces and herbfields at different altitudes. A buttercup ancestor that colonised these habitats faced different selection pressures in each, so populations were selected for different adaptations (leaf shape, size, flowering time, tolerance of cold or of moving scree). During glacial periods, ice covered much of the mountains and split the buttercup populations into separate refuges, with no gene flow between them. Each isolated population changed through natural selection and genetic drift, and when the ice retreated some had become reproductively isolated. Repeated cycles of glaciation multiplied this effect. The result was many species, each adapted to a different niche, evolving quickly from one ancestor: an adaptive radiation.
Step by step
- Orogeny created many new alpine habitats with different conditions.
- Different habitats gave different selection pressures, so populations evolved different adaptations.
- Glaciers split populations into isolated refuges with no gene flow.
- Isolated populations diverged by selection and drift until reproductively isolated.
- Repeated glacial cycles repeated the splitting, giving many species from one ancestor: adaptive radiation.
Full working
- orogenymany new alpine habitats, different selection pressures
- glaciationpopulations isolated, no gene flow
- divergence by selection and driftreproductive isolation
- repeated cyclesmany species from one ancestor: adaptive radiation
Some plant species have formed without any geographical isolation, through polyploidy: a hybrid between two species doubles its chromosome number.
Discuss how polyploidy can produce a new species in a single generation, and compare this with allopatric speciation.
Hint
Why is a hybrid between two species usually sterile, and how does doubling its chromosomes fix this?
Answer
When two related plant species cross, the hybrid has one set of chromosomes from each parent. The two sets are not homologous, so in meiosis they cannot pair up, gametes get unbalanced sets of chromosomes, and the hybrid is sterile (a postzygotic barrier). If a mistake in cell division doubles the hybrid's chromosomes, every chromosome now has an identical partner, so meiosis works and the plant can make fertile gametes. This polyploid can reproduce, by self-fertilisation or with other polyploids, but if it crosses with either parent species the offspring have an odd number of chromosome sets and are sterile. It is therefore reproductively isolated from both parents straight away: a new species formed in one generation, in the same place as its parents (sympatric speciation). Polyploidy is common in plants because many can self-fertilise or reproduce asexually, so a single polyploid plant can start a population. Allopatric speciation, by contrast, needs a geographical barrier to stop gene flow, and then many generations of mutation, selection and drift to build up enough differences for reproductive isolation; it is gradual, usually taking thousands to millions of years. Polyploidy is sudden and needs no barrier, but depends on a rare event and on the new plant being able to reproduce on its own at first.
Step by step
- A hybrid of two species has two non-homologous chromosome sets, so they cannot pair in meiosis: the hybrid is sterile.
- Doubling the chromosomes gives every chromosome a partner, so meiosis works and the plant is fertile.
- Crosses back to either parent give sterile offspring, so the polyploid is instantly reproductively isolated.
- This is sympatric speciation in one generation, common in plants that can self-fertilise or reproduce asexually.
- Allopatric speciation needs a geographical barrier and many generations of divergence.
- So polyploidy is sudden and local; allopatric speciation is slow and needs separation.
Full working
- hybrid: non-homologous setsmeiosis fails | sterile
- chromosome doublinghomologous pairs | fertile polyploid
- polyploid × parentsterile offspring | instant reproductive isolation
- sympatric, one generation
- allopatric: barrier, many generations, gradual
Question Two
Describe stabilising, directional and disruptive selection. For each, state which phenotypes are favoured and what happens to the distribution of the characteristic.
Hint
Picture a bell-shaped curve of a characteristic, such as body size. Which part of the curve does each type of selection favour?
Answer
Stabilising selection favours the average (intermediate) phenotype and acts against both extremes; the distribution narrows around the mean, which stays the same (for example, human birth weight). Directional selection favours one extreme phenotype; the mean shifts in that direction over generations (for example, pesticide resistance). Disruptive selection favours both extremes and acts against the intermediate; the distribution splits towards two peaks, which can lead to two forms in one population.
Step by step
- Stabilising: intermediates favoured, extremes removed; variation decreases, mean unchanged.
- Directional: one extreme favoured; mean shifts that way.
- Disruptive: both extremes favoured, intermediates removed; two peaks form.
Full working
- stabilisingmiddle favoured, curve narrows
- directionalone extreme favoured, mean shifts
- disruptiveboth extremes favoured, two peaks
House sparrows were brought to New Zealand from Britain by acclimatisation societies in the 1860s. Only a few hundred birds were released, and today there are millions.
Explain how the founder effect and genetic drift would have affected the gene pool of New Zealand house sparrows compared with the British population.
Hint
The founders carried only a sample of the British gene pool. What happens to allele frequencies in a small population?
Answer
The founder effect happens when a small group starts a new population. The few hundred sparrows released carried only a random sample of the alleles in the British population, so some alleles were missing and others were present at different frequencies, just by chance. The New Zealand gene pool therefore began with less genetic diversity and different allele frequencies. While the population was small, genetic drift (random changes in allele frequency from one generation to the next) had a large effect, so more alleles could be lost or become more common by chance. As a result, New Zealand sparrows differ genetically from British sparrows, partly by chance rather than by adaptation. Natural selection in the new environment, and new mutations, would add further differences over time.
Step by step
- Founder effect: a few founders carry only a sample of the original gene pool.
- So the new gene pool has fewer alleles and different allele frequencies, by chance.
- In a small population, genetic drift changes allele frequencies a lot each generation.
- More alleles can be lost or fixed, so diversity falls further.
- The NZ population ends up genetically different from the British one, partly by chance.
Full working
- few founderssample of British alleles
- lower diversity, different frequenciesfounder effect
- small populationstrong genetic drift
- NZ gene pool differs from Britain's, partly by chance
In a model, a population of an insect pest on a Pukekohe vegetable farm is sprayed with the same insecticide every season. Before spraying began, 1% of the insects carried an allele, R, that makes them resistant. After 10 seasons, 80% carry R. When the farmer changes to a different insecticide, the frequency of R slowly falls.
Discuss the evolutionary processes that changed the frequency of R, and why it falls after the change.
Hint
Where did R come from, which insects survive each spraying, and is R costly when there is no insecticide?
Answer
The R allele arose by mutation before spraying began, so it was present at a low frequency (1%): the insecticide did not cause the mutation. Spraying is a strong selection pressure. Insects without R are killed, while resistant insects survive and reproduce, passing R on to their offspring. Each season the proportion of resistant insects increases: this is directional selection, shifting the population towards resistance, and the frequency of R rose from 1% to 80% in 10 seasons. The change is fast because insects have short generation times and many offspring, and the selection is strong. When the farmer changes insecticide, the selection pressure in favour of R is removed. If R has a cost (for example, resistant insects use more energy on detoxifying enzymes, so they reproduce slightly less well when there is no insecticide), selection now acts against R and its frequency slowly falls. Gene flow from unsprayed insects nearby, which mostly lack R, also lowers its frequency. The fall is slow because the selection against R is much weaker than the insecticide's selection for it.
Step by step
- R arose by random mutation before spraying, at 1%.
- Spraying kills susceptible insects; resistant ones survive and reproduce: natural selection.
- One extreme (resistance) is favoured each season: directional selection. R rose from 1% to 80%.
- Short generation times and strong selection make the change fast.
- With a different insecticide, there is no advantage to R; if R has a cost, selection acts against it.
- Gene flow from unsprayed populations also lowers R. Weak selection means the fall is slow.
Full working
- R from mutation, 1% before spraying
- spraying: susceptible die, resistant reproducedirectional selection
- R 1% → 80% in 10 seasonsstrong selection, short generations
- insecticide changedno advantage; cost of R | weak selection against
- gene flow from unsprayed insectsR falls slowly
Question Three
Describe what is meant by a phylogeny, a clade and convergent evolution.
Hint
A phylogeny is often drawn as a tree. A clade is one branch of that tree with everything on it.
Answer
A phylogeny is the evolutionary history of a group of species, usually shown as a tree diagram of how they are related through common ancestors. A clade is a group made up of a common ancestor and all of its descendants: one complete branch of the tree. Convergent evolution is when unrelated (or distantly related) species evolve similar features independently, because they face similar selection pressures, for example flightlessness on islands without mammal predators.
Step by step
- Phylogeny: evolutionary relationships, shown as a branching tree.
- Clade: an ancestor and all of its descendants.
- Convergent evolution: similar features evolving separately in unrelated groups because of similar selection pressures.
Full working
- phylogenyevolutionary tree of relationships
- cladeancestor + all descendants
- convergent evolutionsimilar features evolved independently
Ancient DNA has been extracted from moa bones and from the bones of the extinct elephant birds of Madagascar, and compared with the DNA of living birds.
Explain how mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is used to work out how closely related species are.
Hint
Think about how mutations build up over time, and why mtDNA is useful.
Answer
Mutations build up in DNA at a roughly steady rate over time. When two species split from a common ancestor, their DNA starts to change independently, so the longer ago they split, the more differences there are in their base sequences. Comparing the sequences shows how closely related species are: fewer differences means a more recent common ancestor. If the rate of mutation is known, the number of differences can be used as a molecular clock to estimate when the species diverged. mtDNA is often used because it is inherited only from the mother, so it is not shuffled by crossing over (no recombination); it mutates quite quickly, so it shows differences between closely related groups; and there are many copies in each cell, so it survives better in old bones.
Step by step
- Mutations accumulate in DNA at a roughly constant rate.
- After two species split, their DNA changes separately, so differences grow with time.
- Fewer differences = a more recent common ancestor = closer relationship.
- With a known rate, differences act as a molecular clock to date the split.
- mtDNA: maternal inheritance (no recombination), fast mutation, many copies per cell (survives in ancient bones).
Full working
- mutations accumulate at a steady rate
- fewer base differencesmore recent common ancestor
- molecular clockestimate time of divergence
- mtDNA: maternal, no recombination, many copies
Flightless ratites (kiwi, moa, emu, ostriches, rheas and the extinct elephant birds) were once thought to have evolved from one flightless ancestor that lived on the supercontinent Gondwana, and to have drifted apart on the separating continents. DNA studies now show that kiwi are most closely related to the elephant birds of Madagascar, and that moa are most closely related to the tinamous of South America, which can fly.
Discuss what this evidence suggests about how flightlessness evolved in ratites.
Hint
If a flying bird sits inside the ratite family tree, what must have happened to the ability to fly?
Answer
The old idea was vicariance: one flightless ancestor on Gondwana, with the ratite groups separated as the continents drifted apart, so flightlessness evolved only once. The DNA evidence does not fit this. Kiwi's closest relatives are elephant birds in Madagascar, not moa in New Zealand, so the ancestors of kiwi must have reached New Zealand separately from the ancestors of moa. And moa are closest to tinamous, which can fly, so the flying tinamous sit inside the ratite clade. The simplest explanation is that the common ancestor of all these birds could fly, and its descendants dispersed by flying to different landmasses, including New Zealand at least twice (the ancestors of moa and, later, of kiwi). On each landmass, with no ground-dwelling mammal predators (after the dinosaurs died out), flying became less useful and costly, so selection favoured losing flight and becoming large and ground-dwelling. Flightlessness therefore evolved independently several times: an example of convergent evolution, in which similar selection pressures produced similar features in separate lineages. The similar body forms of ratites are not evidence of one flightless ancestor.
Step by step
- Old idea: one flightless ancestor, split by drifting continents (vicariance); flightlessness evolved once.
- Kiwi closest to elephant birds, not moa: kiwi and moa ancestors reached NZ separately.
- Moa closest to the flying tinamous, so a flying group sits inside the ratites.
- So the common ancestor could fly and dispersed by flight to different landmasses.
- With no ground mammal predators, flight was costly and was lost separately in each lineage.
- Flightlessness evolved several times independently: convergent evolution.
Full working
- vicariance idea: one flightless Gondwanan ancestor
- kiwi ~ elephant birds; moa ~ flying tinamous
- ancestor could flydispersed to NZ at least twice
- no mammal predatorsflight lost in each lineage
- flightlessness evolved independentlyconvergent evolution
A Vertex Academy practice paper, written from NZQA's 2026 assessment specification for AS 91605. It is not an NZQA paper. Grades use the 2025 exam's cut scores: 8, 14 and 19 out of 24 for Achieved, Merit and Excellence.