Vertex Learn

Margin of error: the three rules of thumb

WorksheetShare to Classroom

What this lesson covers

  • The margin of error measures sampling variation only, not bias or other errors.
  • The 1/√n rules of thumb are not in the booklet, so they must be learned.
Key idea

One sample, one answer

  • A different sample gives a slightly different result.
  • The margin of error measures how much.
  • It turns a sample result into a range.
Key idea

What a margin of error covers

  • Sampling variation, and nothing else.
  • Not bias, non-response or wording.
  • Keep the two ideas apart.
Worked example

Rule 1: one proportion

  • Learn it: not in the booklet
  • Then form the interval.
  1. MOE ≈ 1/√none proportion
  2. n = 1000: MOE ≈ 1/√1000
  3. = 0.0316 ≈ 3.2%4 decimal places
  4. 42% ± 3.2%
  5. 42 − 3.2 = 38.8
  6. 42 + 3.2 = 45.2
  7. 38.8% to 45.2%
Key idea

Form the interval, then say what it means

  • A margin of error on its own is not an answer.
  • Name the population and the variable.
  • Between 38.8% and 45.2% of all voters.
Key idea

Statistics explorer

Worked example

Four times the sample, half the margin

  • N = 100: 10%.
  • N = 400: 5%.
  • N = 1600: 2.5%.
Four times the sample, half the margin
Key idea

Try it: four times the sample

Worked example

Rule 2: a difference within one group

  • Two results, one sample.
  • One up, the other down.
  • So the margin doubles.
  1. A: 42%, B: 35%same 1000 voters
  2. MOE ≈ 2 × 1/√nsame sample
  3. = 2 × 1/√1000 = 2 × 0.0316
  4. = 0.0632 ≈ 6.3%
  5. 42 − 35 = 7 pointsthe difference
  6. 7 − 6.3 = 0.7
  7. 7 + 6.3 = 13.3
  8. 0.7 to 13.3 points
Worked example

Is zero in the interval?

  • Difference: 7 points ± 6.3.
  • 0.7 to 13.3 points.
  • All above zero: A leads B.
Is zero in the interval?
Worked example

Rule 3: a difference between two groups

  • Two independent samples.
  • Each has its own 1/√n.
  1. A: n = 400, 58% yes
  2. B: n = 625, 47% yes
  3. A: 1/√400 = 1/20 = 5%
  4. B: 1/√625 = 1/25 = 4%
Worked example

1.5 × the average margin of error

  • Average, then times 1.5.
  • Difference ± that margin.
  1. A: 5%, B: 4%
  2. average = (5 + 4)/2 = 4.5%
  3. MOE ≈ 1.5 × 4.5 = 6.75%two samples
  4. 58 − 47 = 11 pointsthe difference
  5. 11 − 6.75 = 4.25
  6. 11 + 6.75 = 17.75
  7. 4.25 to 17.75 points
Key idea

Pick the rule first

  • The wrong rule: a named 2025 error.
  • One proportion, same sample, or two samples?
  • The answer picks the rule.
SituationMOE
One proportion1/√n
Two, same sample2 × 1/√n
Two samples1.5 × average MOE
Key idea

When the rules do not apply

  • Proportions roughly 30% to 70%.
  • A random sample.
  • Never a cover for bias.
ConditionNeeds
Proportionabout 30% to 70%
Samplerandom
Coverssampling error only
Key idea

Where the marks are

  • Achieved: a margin of error and an interval.
  • Merit: interpret it in context.
  • Excellence: right rule, its limits, a claim.
Summary

What to take away

  • Pick the rule, form the interval, then interpret it in context.
One proportion1/√n
Same sample2 × 1/√n
Two samples1.5 × average MOE
Thenform the interval
Only if30% to 70%, random
Not coveredbias, non-response

Common mistakes

  • A 42% and B 35% from the same 1000 voters: MOE ≈ 1/√1000 = 3.2%.
    A difference within one sample uses 2 × 1/√n ≈ 6.3%, because when one result goes up the other goes down.
  • Two towns, n = 400 and n = 625: MOE ≈ 5% + 4% = 9%.
    Two independent samples use 1.5 × the average margin: 1.5 × (5 + 4)/2 = 6.75%.
  • The margin of error is 3.2%, so that is the answer.
    Form the interval, 38.8% to 45.2%, and say what it means for the proportion of all voters.
  • Only 4% said yes, so use MOE ≈ 1/√n as usual.
    The rules of thumb suit proportions roughly 30% to 70%; at 4% the rule overstates the margin of error.
Your turn

Your turn: four questions

  • Decide which rule fits first.
  • Write each interval in full.
GivenFind
1n = 900, 45% say yesinterval
2same poll: 45% v 38%A − B
360% of 100, 45% of 400difference
44% of 1000rule OK?
1
2
3
4
Show answer

1. MOE 1/√900 = 3.3%; 41.7% to 48.3%. 2. Same sample: 2/√900 = 6.7%; difference 7: 0.3 to 13.7 points. 3. Two samples: 1.5 × (10% + 5%)/2 = 11.25%; difference 15: 3.75 to 26.25 points. 4. No: 4% is outside 30% to 70%, so the rule overstates the margin.

Worked example

The answers: questions 1 and 2

  1. 1. MOE ≈ 1/√900 = 1/30one proportion
  2. = 0.0333 ≈ 3.3%
  3. 45 − 3.3 = 41.7, 45 + 3.3 = 48.3
  4. 41.7% to 48.3%
  5. 2. MOE ≈ 2/√900 = 2/30same sample
  6. = 0.0667 ≈ 6.7%
  7. 45 − 38 = 7 pointsthe difference
  8. 7 − 6.7 = 0.3, 7 + 6.7 = 13.7
  9. 0.3 to 13.7 points
Worked example

The answers: questions 3 and 4

  1. 3. 1/√100 = 10%, 1/√400 = 5%two samples
  2. average = (10 + 5)/2 = 7.5%
  3. MOE ≈ 1.5 × 7.5 = 11.25%
  4. 60 − 45 = 15 pointsthe difference
  5. 15 − 11.25 = 3.75
  6. 15 + 11.25 = 26.25
  7. 3.75 to 26.25 points
  8. 4. p = 4%: outside 30% to 70%
  9. rule does not applyit overstates the margin
Your turn

Sample question: Achieved

A random poll of 1600 New Zealand voters finds 38% support a four-year parliamentary term. Use the rule of thumb to find the margin of error, and give the confidence interval.

Hint

For one proportion the margin of error is about 1√n.

Answer

Margin of error 2.5%; interval 35.5% to 40.5%

Step by step
  1. This is one proportion from one sample, so use the first rule: MOE ≈ 1√n.
  2. √1600 = 40, so MOE ≈ 140 = 0.025, which is 2.5%.
  3. The interval is the estimate ± the margin: 38% ± 2.5%.
  4. Lower: 38 − 2.5 = 35.5%. Upper: 38 + 2.5 = 40.5%.
  5. Check the rule applies: 38% is between 30% and 70%, and the sample is random.
  6. Classic mistake: stopping at the margin of error. The answer is the interval.
Full working
  1. MOE ≈ 1√1600 = 140one proportion
  2. = 0.025 = 2.5%
  3. 38 − 2.5 = 35.5, 38 + 2.5 = 40.5
  4. 35.5% to 40.5%
Your turn

Sample questions: Merit

1

A random sample of 900 Aucklanders is asked to choose one of two stadium sites. 52% choose Site A and 41% choose Site B. Find a confidence interval for the difference (A − B) and state what it shows.

Hint

Both results come from the same 900 people, so use the same-sample rule, 2 × 1√n.

Answer

Margin about 6.7%; interval 4.3 to 17.7 percentage points. The whole interval is above zero, so Site A is preferred by Aucklanders.

Step by step
  1. First choose the rule. Both percentages come from one sample of 900, and each person picked one site.
  2. In one sample, when one share goes up the other tends to go down, so the margin for the difference is doubled: 2 × 1√n.
  3. √900 = 30, so the margin is 230 = 0.0667, about 6.7%.
  4. The difference is 52 − 41 = 11 percentage points.
  5. Interval: 11 − 6.7 = 4.3 and 11 + 6.7 = 17.7 percentage points.
  6. Classic mistake: using 1.5 × the average margin. That rule is for two separate samples, not one.
  7. Zero is not inside 4.3 to 17.7. All values are positive.
  8. So I am fairly sure the proportion of Aucklanders choosing Site A is between 4.3 and 17.7 points higher than for Site B: Site A is preferred.
  9. Check: both percentages are between 30% and 70%, so the rule of thumb is reasonable.
Full working
  1. same sampleMOE ≈ 2 × 1√n
  2. 2√900 = 230 ≈ 6.7%
  3. difference = 52 − 41 = 11 points
  4. 11 − 6.7 = 4.3, 11 + 6.7 = 17.7
  5. 4.3 to 17.7 points; all above zero, Site A preferred
2

A random sample of 400 Year 12 students finds 63% use TikTok daily. A separate random sample of 900 adults finds 48% do. Find a confidence interval for the difference (students − adults) and state what it shows.

Hint

Two separate samples: find each margin with 1√n, average them, then multiply by 1.5.

Answer

Margin 6.25%; interval 8.75 to 21.25 percentage points. All above zero, so a higher proportion of Year 12 students than adults use TikTok daily.

Step by step
  1. Choose the rule. These are two independent samples, so use 1.5 × the average margin of error.
  2. Students: 1√400 = 120 = 5%.
  3. Adults: 1√900 = 130 = 3.33%.
  4. Average: 5 + 3.332 = 4.17%.
  5. Margin for the difference: 1.5 × 4.17 = 6.25%.
  6. Difference: 63 − 48 = 15 percentage points.
  7. Interval: 15 − 6.25 = 8.75 and 15 + 6.25 = 21.25 points.
  8. Zero is not inside, so I am fairly sure the proportion of Year 12 students who use TikTok daily is between 8.75 and 21.25 points higher than for adults.
  9. Classic mistake: adding the two margins, 5 + 3.33 = 8.33. That overstates the margin; the rule is 1.5 × the average.
Full working
  1. two samplesMOE ≈ 1.5 × average MOE
  2. 1√400 = 5%, 1√900 = 3.33%
  3. average = 5 + 3.332 = 4.171.5 × 4.17 = 6.25%
  4. difference = 63 − 48 = 15 points
  5. 15 − 6.25 = 8.75, 15 + 6.25 = 21.25
  6. 8.75 to 21.25 points; students higher
Your turn

Sample questions: Excellence

1

In a mayoral poll, Candidate A has 47% and Candidate B has 42%, both from the same random sample. A newspaper with a sample of 1000 says "A is ahead". Is this justified? What is the smallest sample size for which the same percentages would let you claim A is ahead? Give one reason the claim could still be wrong with that sample size.

Hint

Same sample, so the margin for the difference is 2√n; A is ahead only if the whole interval for the 5-point difference is above zero.

Answer

With n = 1000 the margin is about 6.3%, giving −1.3 to 11.3 points, so the claim is not justified. You need 2√n < 5%, so n > 1600: at least 1601 people. Even then the margin covers sampling variation only; bias such as non-response, or voters changing their minds, could still make the claim wrong.

Step by step
  1. Both candidates' shares come from one sample, so the margin for the difference is 2 × 1√n.
  2. With n = 1000: 2√1000 = 2 × 0.0316 = 0.0632, about 6.3%.
  3. The difference is 47 − 42 = 5 points. Interval: 5 − 6.3 = −1.3 to 5 + 6.3 = 11.3.
  4. Zero is inside, so B could be level or even ahead. The newspaper's claim is not justified.
  5. Now the smallest n. A is ahead only if the margin is less than the 5-point difference.
  6. So 2√n < 0.05, which means √n > 2 ÷ 0.05 = 40, so n > 1600.
  7. At n = 1600 the margin is exactly 5%, and the interval is 0 to 10. It still touches zero, so that is not enough.
  8. So at least 1601 people are needed.
  9. Even then, a margin of error describes sampling variation and nothing else.
  10. In context: supporters of one candidate may be less likely to answer polls (non-response bias), or voters may change their minds before election day.
  11. So the poll would support A being ahead at the time of polling, not prove it.
Full working
  1. same sampleMOE ≈ 2√n
  2. n = 1000: 2√1000 ≈ 6.3%5 ± 6.3 = −1.3 to 11.3, zero inside
  3. need 2√n < 0.05margin less than the 5-point gap
  4. √n > 40, so n > 1600
  5. n = 1600 gives 0 to 10, touching zeroneed n ≥ 1601
  6. MOE covers sampling error onlynon-response, changing minds
  7. not justified at 1000; need at least 1601
2

A random sample of 2500 NZ adults finds 4% rode an e-scooter yesterday. (a) Use the rule of thumb 1√n to give an interval. (b) A more exact margin of error is 1.96 × √(p(1 − p) ÷ n). Use it with p = 0.04 to give a second interval. (c) Show that the exact formula gives about 1√n when p = 0.5, and use this to explain why the rule of thumb is only used for proportions between about 30% and 70%.

Hint

In (c), put p = 0.5 into p(1 − p) and notice 1.96 × 0.5 is almost 1; then compare p(1 − p) for 4%.

Answer

(a) 2% to 6%. (b) Margin 0.77%, so 3.23% to 4.77%. (c) With p = 0.5, 1.96 × √(0.25 ÷ n) = 0.98√n ≈ 1√n. p(1 − p) is largest at p = 0.5, so the rule of thumb gives the biggest possible margin. Between 30% and 70% the exact margin is still close to it (at 30% it is about 0.9√n), but at 4% the rule gives a margin about 2.6 times too big.

Step by step
  1. (a) Rule of thumb: 1√2500 = 150 = 0.02 = 2%. Interval 4 ± 2: 2% to 6%.
  2. (b) Put p = 0.04 and n = 2500 into 1.96 × √(p(1 − p) ÷ n).
  3. p(1 − p) = 0.04 × 0.96 = 0.0384. Divide by 2500: 0.00001536. Square root: 0.003919.
  4. Multiply by 1.96: 0.00768, about 0.77%. Interval 4 ± 0.77: 3.23% to 4.77%.
  5. The two intervals are very different: the rule of thumb is much wider.
  6. (c) Put p = 0.5: p(1 − p) = 0.5 × 0.5 = 0.25, and √0.25 = 0.5.
  7. So the exact margin is 1.96 × 0.5 ÷ √n = 0.98√n, which is almost exactly 1√n. That is where the rule of thumb comes from.
  8. p(1 − p) is biggest when p = 0.5, so the rule of thumb is the largest margin a proportion can have.
  9. Near 0.5 this hardly matters. At p = 0.3, 1.96 × √0.21 = 0.90, so the margin is about 0.9√n, still close to 1√n.
  10. At p = 0.04, 1.96 × √0.0384 = 0.38, so the true margin is about 0.38√n. The rule overstates it: 2 ÷ 0.77 ≈ 2.6 times too big.
  11. So outside about 30% to 70% the rule of thumb gives intervals that are far too wide.
Full working
  1. (a) 1√2500 = 2%4 ± 2 = 2% to 6%
  2. (b) 1.96 × √(0.04 × 0.96 ÷ 2500) = 0.0077
  3. 4 ± 0.77 = 3.23% to 4.77%
  4. (c) p = 0.5: 1.96 × √(0.25 ÷ n) = 0.98√n ≈ 1√n
  5. p(1 − p) is largest at p = 0.5rule is the maximum margin
  6. p = 0.3: 0.90√n; p = 0.04: 0.38√nclose inside 30% to 70%, far off outside
  7. 2% to 6%; 3.23% to 4.77%; the rule overstates the margin outside 30% to 70%
Try it

Projectile Sampling Distributions

Full screen · PhET Interactive Simulations, University of Colorado Boulder, CC BY 4.0

Practice

Practise this

Worksheet with answersWithout answersDownload PDF
Report a mistake

More in AS 91584

Is your child on track?

Take the free placement test