Vertex Learn

NCEA Level 3 Earth and Space Science revision

What comes up

AS 91413

Question 1 · Upwelling off Peru

a
Excellence

For most of the year, south-east trade winds blow north along the coast of Peru. Cold water rises to the surface near the coast, and the waters off Peru support one of the largest fisheries in the world.

Discuss how the wind along the coast of Peru causes upwelling, and why the upwelling makes these waters so productive.

In your answer, consider:

• the Coriolis effect and Ekman transport

• where the upwelled water comes from and what it carries

• how the upwelling affects productivity.

Hint

In the Southern Hemisphere, moving water is deflected to the left. If the wind blows north along a coast on the west side of a continent, which way does the surface water end up moving?

Answer

Wind blowing over the sea drags the surface water along by friction. Because the Earth rotates, moving water is deflected by the Coriolis effect, to the left in the Southern Hemisphere. Each layer of water drags the one below and is deflected further, so the average movement of the wind-driven surface layer (Ekman transport) is about 90° to the left of the wind. Off Peru the wind blows north along the coast, so Ekman transport moves the surface water west, away from the coast. Water must replace it, and it can only come from below: cold water rises from beneath the thermocline near the coast (upwelling). This deep water is rich in nutrients such as nitrate and phosphate, because dead organisms and waste sink and decompose at depth, where there is too little light for phytoplankton to use them. When the upwelled water reaches the sunlit surface, phytoplankton use the nutrients and sunlight to photosynthesise and multiply rapidly. This large base of the food web supports huge numbers of zooplankton and small fish such as anchoveta, and the seabirds, larger fish and fisheries that feed on them. Because the trade winds blow for most of the year, the supply of nutrients is renewed almost continuously, which is why the region is so productive, and why it suffers when the winds weaken, as in an El Niño.

Step by step
  1. Wind blowing over the sea drags the surface water along, by friction.
  2. Because the Earth rotates, moving water is deflected by the Coriolis effect: to the left in the Southern Hemisphere.
  3. Each layer of water drags the layer below it, and each is deflected a bit further. Averaged over the wind-driven layer, the water moves about 90° to the left of the wind. This is Ekman transport.
  4. Off Peru the wind blows north along the coast, so 90° to the left is west: the surface water is pushed away from the coast.
  5. That water has to be replaced, and the only place it can come from is below. Cold water rises from beneath the thermocline near the coast. This is upwelling.
  6. Deep water is rich in nutrients such as nitrate and phosphate. Dead organisms and waste sink and decompose at depth, where it is too dark for phytoplankton to use the nutrients.
  7. When upwelling brings that water into the sunlit surface layer, phytoplankton have both light and nutrients, so they photosynthesise and multiply fast.
  8. Phytoplankton are the base of the food web: zooplankton eat them, small fish such as anchoveta eat the zooplankton, and seabirds, bigger fish and fisheries follow.
  9. The trade winds blow for most of the year, so the nutrients are renewed almost all the time. That is why the waters are so productive, and why they suffer when the winds weaken in an El Niño.
Full working
  1. wind drags the surface waterfriction
  2. Coriolis effect deflects moving water to the left in the Southern Hemisphere
  3. Ekman transport: about 90° to the left of the wind
  4. wind north along the coastsurface water moves west, offshore
  5. replaced from belowcold water upwells from beneath the thermocline
  6. deep water is nutrient-richdecomposition at depth, too dark for phytoplankton
  7. nutrients plus sunlightphytoplankton bloom, food web, big fishery
  8. winds blow most of the yearnutrients renewed; weak winds (El Niño) cut the supply
AS 91413

Question 2 · Ocean acidification

a
Excellence

Since the industrial revolution, the average pH of the surface ocean has fallen from about 8.2 to about 8.1, as the ocean takes up some of the carbon dioxide released by burning fossil fuels. New Zealand's shellfish, such as pāua and Greenshell mussels, build their shells from calcium carbonate.

Discuss how the ocean takes up carbon dioxide, why this lowers the ocean's pH, and the likely effects on organisms that build calcium carbonate shells.

In your answer, consider:

• the physical (solubility) pump and the biological pump

• the chemical reactions involved

• what a fall of 0.1 in pH means.

Hint

Carbon dioxide does more than dissolve: it reacts with water. Follow the hydrogen ions, and ask what they do to the carbonate ions a shell needs.

Answer

Carbon dioxide dissolves into the surface ocean from the air, and more dissolves when the atmosphere holds more of it. Cold water can hold more dissolved gas than warm water, and in places such as the Southern Ocean cold, dense surface water sinks and carries the dissolved carbon into the deep ocean (the physical, or solubility, pump). Phytoplankton also take up carbon dioxide in photosynthesis; when they and the organisms that eat them die or produce waste, some of that carbon sinks into the deep ocean (the biological pump). Both pumps move carbon away from the surface, so the surface can take up more. Dissolved carbon dioxide reacts with water to form carbonic acid, which releases hydrogen ions and hydrogen carbonate ions: CO₂ + H₂O → H₂CO₃ → H⁺ + HCO₃⁻. More hydrogen ions means a lower pH. pH is a logarithmic scale, so a fall of 0.1 means about 26% more hydrogen ions (10 to the power 0.1 ≈ 1.26), often rounded to 30%. Many of the extra hydrogen ions react with carbonate ions: H⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → HCO₃⁻, so fewer carbonate ions are left. Shell-building organisms such as pāua and mussels make their shells from calcium carbonate (Ca²⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → CaCO₃), so with fewer carbonate ions they must use more energy to build and maintain their shells, which may grow thinner or more slowly, and in more acidic water existing shell can start to dissolve. Young larvae, building their first shells, are especially vulnerable. Because these organisms are food for others, and support fisheries and aquaculture, the effects can spread through food webs and the economy.

Step by step
  1. Carbon dioxide dissolves into the surface ocean from the air. The more CO₂ in the air, the more dissolves.
  2. Physical (solubility) pump: cold water holds more dissolved gas. Where cold, dense surface water sinks, as around Antarctica, it carries dissolved carbon into the deep ocean.
  3. Biological pump: phytoplankton take up CO₂ in photosynthesis. When they, and the animals that eat them, die or produce waste, some of the carbon sinks to the deep ocean.
  4. Both pumps take carbon away from the surface, so the surface can take up more from the air.
  5. Dissolved CO₂ reacts with water to make carbonic acid, which releases hydrogen ions: CO₂ + H₂O → H₂CO₃ → H⁺ + HCO₃⁻.
  6. More hydrogen ions means a lower pH: the ocean is becoming more acidic (it is still alkaline, above 7).
  7. pH is a logarithmic scale. A fall of 0.1 means 10 to the power 0.1 ≈ 1.26 times as many hydrogen ions: about 26% more, often rounded to 30%.
  8. Many of the extra hydrogen ions react with carbonate ions: H⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → HCO₃⁻. So there are fewer carbonate ions in the water.
  9. Pāua and mussels build their shells from calcium carbonate: Ca²⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → CaCO₃. Fewer carbonate ions makes that harder.
  10. They must use more energy to build and repair shell, so shells may grow thinner or more slowly, and in more acidic water shell can start to dissolve. Larvae making their first shells are most at risk.
  11. These animals feed others and support fisheries and aquaculture, so the effects can spread through food webs and the economy.
Full working
  1. CO₂ dissolves from the airmore in the air, more dissolves
  2. solubility pump: cold water holds more; sinking water carries carbon down
  3. biological pump: photosynthesis, then sinking dead organisms and waste
  4. CO₂ + H₂O → H₂CO₃ → H⁺ + HCO₃⁻more H⁺, lower pH
  5. pH 8.2 to 8.1: 10 to the power 0.1 ≈ 1.26about 26% more H⁺
  6. H⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → HCO₃⁻fewer carbonate ions
  7. Ca²⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → CaCO₃ harder to makethinner shells, slower growth, larvae at risk
  8. shellfish feed others and support aquacultureeffects spread
AS 91413

Question 3 · El Niño and New Zealand

a
Excellence

In a normal year, the trade winds blow from east to west across the tropical Pacific. During an El Niño, the trade winds weaken, and the sea surface off South America becomes unusually warm. NIWA says El Niño tends to bring New Zealand more westerly and south-westerly winds, with cooler conditions and a greater chance of drought in the east.

Discuss how ocean circulation and the thermocline across the tropical Pacific change during an El Niño, and how this can affect New Zealand's weather.

In your answer, consider:

• the normal pattern of winds, warm water and the thermocline

• how these change when the trade winds weaken

• the effects on upwelling off South America

• the link to New Zealand's weather.

Hint

In a normal year, the trade winds pile warm water up in the west. What happens to that pile, and to the thermocline, when the winds ease?

Answer

In a normal year the trade winds blow east to west across the tropical Pacific, dragging warm surface water westward so that it piles up near Indonesia and northern Australia as a deep warm pool. The thermocline, the boundary between warm surface water and cold deep water, is therefore deep in the west and shallow in the east. Off South America, the winds and Ekman transport draw cold, nutrient-rich water up from beneath the shallow thermocline. Warm water in the west heats the air, which rises and brings heavy rain there, while cool water in the east keeps the air dry and sinking. During an El Niño the trade winds weaken, and in strong events can reverse in the west. The piled-up warm water spreads back eastward, the thermocline deepens in the east and becomes flatter across the Pacific, and upwelling off South America now brings up warm, nutrient-poor water from above the thermocline. The sea surface off South America warms, productivity falls and fisheries such as anchoveta decline. The area of rising air and heavy rain shifts east towards the central Pacific, changing the pattern of high and low pressure across the Pacific. For New Zealand, this tends to bring more westerly and south-westerly winds, which make conditions cooler than normal, wetter in the west, and drier in the east, where the mountains shelter the land and drought becomes more likely. NIWA notes that El Niño explains only part of New Zealand's year-to-year variation, so its effects are tendencies rather than certainties.

Step by step
  1. Normal year: the trade winds blow east to west across the tropical Pacific and drag warm surface water west.
  2. The warm water piles up near Indonesia and northern Australia as a deep warm pool. So the thermocline (warm water above, cold below) is deep in the west and shallow in the east.
  3. Off South America, the winds and Ekman transport bring cold, nutrient-rich water up from below the shallow thermocline: upwelling.
  4. Warm water in the west heats the air, which rises and brings heavy rain there. Cool water in the east keeps the air sinking and dry.
  5. El Niño: the trade winds weaken, and in strong events can even reverse in the west.
  6. The piled-up warm water flows back east. The thermocline deepens in the east and flattens across the Pacific.
  7. Upwelling off South America now draws on warm, nutrient-poor water from above the deeper thermocline, so the surface warms and productivity and fisheries fall.
  8. The rising air and heavy rain move east with the warm water, which changes the pressure pattern across the Pacific.
  9. For New Zealand that tends to mean more westerly and south-westerly winds: cooler than normal, wetter in the west, and drier in the east, in the shelter of the mountains, with more risk of drought.
  10. NIWA notes El Niño explains only part of our year-to-year variation, so these are tendencies, not certainties.
Full working
  1. normal: trade winds east to westwarm pool piles up in the west
  2. thermocline deep in the west, shallow in the eastcold upwelling off South America
  3. rising air and rain over the warm west, sinking dry air in the east
  4. El Niño: trade winds weakenwarm water flows back east
  5. thermocline deepens in the east, flattensupwelled water warm and nutrient-poor
  6. fisheries off South America declinerain and rising air shift east
  7. NZ: more westerly and south-westerly windscooler, wetter west, drier east
  8. a tendency, not a certainty
AS 91414

Question 4 · Why New Zealand is in the westerlies

a
Excellence

New Zealand lies between about 34°S and 47°S, and most of its weather arrives from the west.

Discuss why New Zealand lies in a belt of westerly winds.

In your answer, consider:

• why the Sun heats the Earth unevenly

• the Hadley cell and the subtropical high-pressure belt

• the Ferrel cell and the Coriolis effect

• why the winds over New Zealand blow from the west.

Hint

Start at the equator with rising air, and follow it to where it sinks. Then follow the surface air that flows away from the sinking zone towards the pole, and remember which way it is deflected in the Southern Hemisphere.

Answer

Near the equator the Sun is high in the sky all year, so each square metre receives much more solar radiation than near the poles, where the same sunlight arrives at a low angle and is spread over a larger area. The surplus heat at the equator must be moved towards the poles, and the atmosphere does this in three circulation cells in each hemisphere. At the equator, hot, moist air rises (low pressure), flows towards the pole high in the troposphere, cools, and sinks at about 30°S, forming a belt of high pressure: the subtropical highs. This loop is the Hadley cell. At the surface, air flows away from the subtropical high in both directions. Between about 30°S and 60°S, in the Ferrel cell, surface air flows towards the pole, from the subtropical high towards the low pressure near 60°S. Because the Earth rotates, moving air is deflected by the Coriolis effect, to the left in the Southern Hemisphere, and the effect is stronger at higher latitudes. So air flowing south (poleward) is turned to the left, towards the east, and becomes a wind blowing from the west: the westerlies. New Zealand, between about 34°S and 47°S, sits in this belt, so its weather systems arrive from the Tasman Sea in the west. With little land in the Southern Hemisphere at these latitudes to slow them, the westerlies are strong and persistent, the 'Roaring Forties'.

Step by step
  1. Near the equator the Sun is high all year, so each square metre gets much more solar radiation than near the poles, where the same light comes in at a low angle and spreads over a bigger area.
  2. So the equator has a heat surplus and the poles a deficit, and the atmosphere moves heat towards the poles in three cells in each hemisphere.
  3. Hadley cell: at the equator hot, moist air rises, giving low pressure and heavy rain. High up it flows towards the pole, cools, and sinks at about 30°S.
  4. Sinking air at about 30°S makes a belt of high pressure: the subtropical highs.
  5. At the surface, air flows out of the subtropical high in both directions. Between about 30°S and 60°S, in the Ferrel cell, it flows towards the pole, towards low pressure near 60°S.
  6. Because the Earth rotates, moving air is deflected by the Coriolis effect: to the left in the Southern Hemisphere, more strongly at higher latitudes.
  7. Air heading south is turned to its left, which is east. So it becomes a wind blowing from the west: the westerlies.
  8. New Zealand, from about 34°S to 47°S, sits in this belt, so most of its weather arrives from the Tasman Sea in the west.
  9. With little land at these latitudes in the Southern Hemisphere to slow them, the westerlies are strong and steady: the Roaring Forties.
Full working
  1. high Sun at the equator, low Sun at the polesuneven heating
  2. Hadley cell: rises at the equator, sinks at about 30°Ssubtropical highs
  3. Ferrel cell: surface air flows poleward from 30°S towards 60°S
  4. Coriolis effect: deflected to the left in the Southern Hemisphere
  5. poleward air turned eastwinds from the west: westerlies
  6. New Zealand 34°S to 47°Sin the westerly belt, weather arrives from the west
  7. little land to slow themthe Roaring Forties
AS 91414

Question 5 · The Canterbury nor'wester

a
Excellence

A north-west wind blows moist air from the Tasman Sea over the Southern Alps. It rains heavily on the West Coast, while Canterbury has a hot, dry nor'wester.

A worked example, using typical rates of cooling and warming: air at 18 °C at sea level on the West Coast cools at about 10 °C per km as it rises, until it becomes saturated at 800 m. It then cools at about 6 °C per km up to 2500 m. It descends to Christchurch, near sea level, warming at about 10 °C per km.

Discuss why the air reaches Christchurch much warmer and drier than it was on the West Coast.

In your answer, consider:

• why rising air cools and sinking air warms

• why the rate of cooling changes once the air is saturated

• the role of latent heat

• the temperature of the air at each stage.

Hint

Work out the temperature at 800 m, at the top, and back at sea level. The two rising rates differ because of something released when water vapour condenses.

Answer

Rising air moves into lower pressure, so it expands; expanding takes energy from the air, so it cools (and sinking air is compressed, so it warms). Unsaturated air cools at about 10 °C per km (the dry adiabatic rate). The air starts at 18 °C, so after rising 800 m it has cooled by 8 °C to 10 °C, and is saturated: water vapour starts to condense into cloud droplets. Condensation releases latent heat, which partly offsets the cooling from expansion, so saturated air cools more slowly, here about 6 °C per km. From 800 m to 2500 m (1.7 km) it cools by about 10 °C, to about 0 °C. Much of the condensed water falls as heavy rain on the West Coast, so the water vapour, and the latent heat it carried, has been taken out of the air and the heat left in the air. Descending on the Canterbury side, the air is compressed and warms, and because it is now unsaturated (there is no cloud to evaporate), it warms at the dry rate of about 10 °C per km: 2.5 km × 10 = 25 °C warmer, reaching about 25 °C near Christchurch. The air arrives 7 °C warmer than it started because it cooled at the slower saturated rate on the way up but warmed at the faster dry rate on the way down: the latent heat released by condensation on the West Coast stays in the air. It is also much drier, because it lost its moisture as rain on the windward side, which is why Canterbury gets a hot, dry nor'wester in the rain shadow of the Alps.

Step by step
  1. Rising air moves into lower pressure and expands. Expanding takes energy from the air, so it cools. Sinking air is compressed, so it warms.
  2. Unsaturated air cools at about 10 °C per km: the dry adiabatic rate.
  3. Start at 18 °C. Rising 800 m: 0.8 km × 10 = 8 °C cooler, so 10 °C. Now the air is saturated.
  4. Water vapour condenses into cloud droplets, and condensation releases latent heat into the air.
  5. That heat partly offsets the cooling, so saturated air cools more slowly: about 6 °C per km.
  6. From 800 m to 2500 m is 1.7 km: 1.7 × 6 ≈ 10 °C cooler, so about 0 °C at the top.
  7. Much of the condensed water falls as rain on the West Coast. The moisture is gone, but the latent heat it released stays in the air.
  8. On the way down there is no cloud left to evaporate, so the air warms at the dry rate, about 10 °C per km: 2.5 km × 10 = 25 °C warmer, so about 25 °C at Christchurch.
  9. It arrives about 7 °C warmer than it started, because it cooled slowly (saturated) going up but warmed fast (dry) coming down.
  10. And it is much drier, because it dropped its water as rain on the windward side. Canterbury is in the rain shadow: a hot, dry nor'wester.
Full working
  1. rising air expands and cools; sinking air is compressed and warms
  2. dry rate about 10 °C per km: 18 − 0.8 × 10 = 10 °C at 800 msaturated
  3. condensation releases latent heatsaturated rate about 6 °C per km
  4. 10 − 1.7 × 6 ≈ 0 °C at 2500 m
  5. rain falls on the West Coastmoisture removed, latent heat kept
  6. descends at the dry rate: 0 + 2.5 × 10 = 25 °C at Christchurch
  7. about 7 °C warmer and much drierrain shadow nor'wester
AS 91414

Question 6 · Carbon dioxide and the energy balance

a
Excellence

NIWA has measured carbon dioxide at Baring Head, near Wellington, since December 1972. The level then was about 326 parts per million (ppm); the average for 2023 was 416 ppm.

Discuss how the increase in carbon dioxide affects the Earth's energy balance and leads to warming.

In your answer, consider:

• incoming shortwave and outgoing longwave radiation

• how greenhouse gases interact with radiation

• the effect of more carbon dioxide on the energy balance

• feedbacks that can strengthen the warming.

Hint

Sunlight comes in at short wavelengths; the Earth gives out long wavelengths. Which one does carbon dioxide absorb? Then think about what happens when a warmer atmosphere holds more water vapour, and when ice melts.

Answer

The Sun's radiation arrives mostly as shortwave radiation (visible light, with some ultraviolet and near infrared), which passes through the atmosphere largely unabsorbed. Some is reflected by clouds, ice and other bright surfaces (albedo); the rest is absorbed by the surface, which warms. The warm surface emits longwave (infrared) radiation. Greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, water vapour and methane let most shortwave radiation through but absorb longwave radiation, because longwave radiation makes their molecules vibrate. They then re-emit it in all directions, including back down towards the surface, so the surface and lower atmosphere are warmer than they would be without them (the greenhouse effect). The Earth's temperature is steady when the energy it absorbs from the Sun equals the energy it radiates to space. As carbon dioxide rises (from about 326 ppm in 1972 to 416 ppm in 2023 at Baring Head, about 28% more), more longwave radiation is absorbed and re-emitted downward, and less escapes to space, so the Earth absorbs more energy than it loses. It warms until it gives out enough longwave radiation to restore the balance at a higher temperature. Feedbacks strengthen this: warmer air holds more water vapour, itself a greenhouse gas, which traps more longwave radiation; and melting snow and sea ice expose darker land and ocean, which lowers the albedo, so more sunlight is absorbed. These feedbacks make the final warming larger than the carbon dioxide increase alone would cause.

Step by step
  1. Sunlight arrives mostly as shortwave radiation: visible light, with some ultraviolet and near infrared. It passes through the atmosphere largely unabsorbed.
  2. Some is reflected by clouds, ice and other bright surfaces (albedo). The rest is absorbed by the surface, which warms.
  3. The warm surface emits longwave (infrared) radiation.
  4. Greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide, water vapour, methane) let shortwave through, but absorb longwave, which makes their molecules vibrate.
  5. They re-emit that energy in all directions, including back down, so the surface and lower atmosphere stay warmer: the greenhouse effect.
  6. The temperature is steady when the energy absorbed from the Sun equals the energy radiated to space.
  7. Baring Head: 326 ppm in 1972 to 416 ppm in 2023, about 28% more carbon dioxide.
  8. More carbon dioxide absorbs and re-emits more longwave radiation, so less escapes to space. The Earth absorbs more energy than it loses, and warms.
  9. It keeps warming until it radiates enough longwave to balance again, at a higher temperature.
  10. Feedbacks make it bigger. Warmer air holds more water vapour, another greenhouse gas, which traps more longwave.
  11. Melting snow and sea ice expose darker land and ocean, lowering the albedo, so more sunlight is absorbed.
  12. So the final warming is larger than the carbon dioxide alone would cause.
Full working
  1. shortwave in, mostly unabsorbedsome reflected (albedo), rest absorbed by the surface
  2. warm surface emits longwave (infrared)
  3. greenhouse gases absorb longwave and re-emit it in all directionsgreenhouse effect
  4. balance: energy in = energy out
  5. 326 ppm to 416 ppm: (416 − 326) ÷ 326 ≈ 28% more CO₂
  6. more longwave trapped, less escapesenergy in > energy out, Earth warms
  7. new balance at a higher temperature
  8. water vapour feedback and ice-albedo feedbackwarming amplified

Past papers

AS 91413

AS 91414

NCEA Level 3 Science