Vertex Learn

NCEA Level 3 Statistics revision

What comes up

AS 91585

Question 1 · Venn diagrams

a
Achieved

A Queenstown tourism survey asked 1500 visitors which of three activities they did during their stay: a bungy jump, a jet boat ride, or the gondola.

• 420 did a bungy jump, 610 rode a jet boat and 880 rode the gondola.

• 240 did both a bungy jump and a jet boat ride.

• 300 did both a jet boat ride and the gondola.

• 220 did both a bungy jump and the gondola.

• 90 did all three.

Estimate the probability that a randomly selected visitor from the survey did exactly one of the three activities.

Hint

Draw a Venn diagram with three circles. Put the 90 in the centre first, then fill the 'two only' regions, then the 'one only' regions.

Answer

Bungy only 50, jet boat only 160, gondola only 450, so 660 visitors did exactly one activity. P(exactly one) = 6601500 = 0.44.

Step by step
  1. Draw three overlapping circles: B (bungy), J (jet boat) and G (gondola).
  2. Start in the centre: 90 did all three.
  3. Two only: bungy and jet boat only = 240 − 90 = 150. Jet boat and gondola only = 300 − 90 = 210. Bungy and gondola only = 220 − 90 = 130.
  4. One only: take everything else in that circle away from its total.
  5. Bungy only = 420 − 150 − 130 − 90 = 50.
  6. Jet boat only = 610 − 150 − 210 − 90 = 160.
  7. Gondola only = 880 − 210 − 130 − 90 = 450.
  8. Exactly one activity: 50 + 160 + 450 = 660 visitors.
  9. P(exactly one) = 6601500 = 0.44.
  10. Check: the eight regions add to 1500 (50 + 160 + 450 + 150 + 210 + 130 + 90, plus 260 who did none).
  11. Classic mistake: subtracting only the 'both' totals (420 − 240 − 220) and forgetting that the 90 has then been taken away twice.
Full working
  1. all three = 90centre of the Venn diagram
  2. two only: 150, 210, 130subtract 90 from each pair
  3. B only = 420 − 150 − 130 − 90 = 50
  4. J only = 610 − 150 − 210 − 90 = 160
  5. G only = 880 − 210 − 130 − 90 = 450
  6. exactly one = 50 + 160 + 450 = 660
  7. P(exactly one) = 6601500 = 0.44
AS 91585

Question 2 · Independent or mutually exclusive

b
Merit

A Queenstown tourism survey asked 1500 visitors which activities they did. 420 did a bungy jump, 610 rode a jet boat, and 240 did both a bungy jump and a jet boat ride.

Interpret the relationship between the events 'visitor did a bungy jump' and 'visitor rode a jet boat'. As part of your answer, explain whether these two events are independent, and whether they are mutually exclusive.

Use calculations and statistical reasoning to support your answer.

Hint

Compare P(bungy | jet boat) with P(bungy). If knowing one event changes the chance of the other, they are not independent. Mutually exclusive means they can never happen together.

Answer

P(B) = 4201500 = 0.28 but P(B | J) = 240610 = 0.3934. Visitors who rode a jet boat were more likely to bungy jump than visitors in general, so the events are not independent (also P(B) × P(J) = 0.1139 but P(B and J) = 0.16). They are not mutually exclusive because 240 visitors did both. In context, visitors who choose one thrill activity are more likely to choose another.

Step by step
  1. Let B = did a bungy jump and J = rode a jet boat.
  2. P(B) = 4201500 = 0.28. This is the chance for any visitor.
  3. P(B | J) means: of the jet boat riders only, what fraction did a bungy jump? Only the 610 jet boat riders count, so P(B | J) = 240610 = 0.3934.
  4. 0.3934 is bigger than 0.28. Knowing a visitor rode a jet boat raises the chance they bungy jumped, so B and J are not independent.
  5. The multiplication test says the same: P(B) × P(J) = 0.28 × 0.4067 = 0.1139, but P(B and J) = 2401500 = 0.16. These are not equal.
  6. Mutually exclusive means the events cannot happen together. 240 visitors did both, so P(B and J) = 0.16, not 0. They are not mutually exclusive.
  7. In context: there is a positive relationship. Visitors who like one adrenaline activity are more likely to do another one too.
  8. Classic mistake: mixing up the two ideas. Independent means one event does not change the chance of the other; mutually exclusive means they never happen together.
Full working
  1. P(B) = 4201500 = 0.28
  2. P(BJ) = 240610 = 0.3934 | only the 610 jet boat riders
  3. 0.3934 ≠ 0.28, so not independentalso P(B) × P(J) = 0.1139 ≠ 0.16
  4. P(B and J) = 0.16 ≠ 0, so not mutually exclusive
  5. Not independent (jet boat riders more likely to bungy), not mutually exclusive
AS 91585

Question 3 · Reverse conditional probability

d
Excellence

A Queenstown jet boat company takes bookings two ways. 35% of bookings are made online and the rest are made in person at an i-SITE visitor centre. Records show that 6% of online bookings are no-shows (the customer does not turn up), and 2% of i-SITE bookings are no-shows.

(i) Given that a booking was a no-show, calculate the probability that it was made online.

(ii) The manager says: 'Most of our no-shows are online bookings, even though most of our bookings are made at the i-SITE.' Use probabilities to explain how both parts of this statement can be true.

Hint

Draw a tree: first branch online or i-SITE, second branch no-show or turns up. P(no-show) is the sum of two branch products. For (ii), compare the risk of a no-show for each type of booking.

Answer

(i) P(no-show) = 0.35 × 0.06 + 0.65 × 0.02 = 0.034. P(online | no-show) = 0.0210.034 = 0.6176. (ii) Only 35% of bookings are online, but the no-show risk for online bookings is 0.060.02 = 3 times the i-SITE risk. That higher risk outweighs the smaller share, so 61.8% of no-shows are online bookings while 65% of all bookings are i-SITE ones.

Step by step
  1. (i) Draw a tree diagram. First branches: online 0.35, i-SITE 0.65.
  2. Second branches: online then no-show 0.06; i-SITE then no-show 0.02.
  3. Multiply along each branch: P(online and no-show) = 0.35 × 0.06 = 0.021. P(i-SITE and no-show) = 0.65 × 0.02 = 0.013.
  4. Add the no-show branches: P(no-show) = 0.021 + 0.013 = 0.034.
  5. Given a no-show, only those two branches count. P(online | no-show) = 0.0210.034 = 0.6176.
  6. Classic mistake: answering 0.06. That is P(no-show | online), the other way round.
  7. (ii) 'Most bookings are i-SITE' is true: 65% are.
  8. 'Most no-shows are online' is also true: from (i), 61.8% of no-shows are online.
  9. The reason is the risk. An online booking is a no-show with probability 0.06; an i-SITE booking with probability 0.02.
  10. Relative risk = 0.060.02 = 3. An online booking is three times as likely to be a no-show.
  11. So even though online bookings are the smaller group, each one is much more likely to be a no-show, and online bookings make up 0.021 out of the 0.034 no-show probability.
  12. In context: customers who book online have not met staff in person and may book several activities at once, so they may be more likely to drop one.
Full working
  1. P(online and no-show) = 0.35 × 0.06 = 0.021
  2. P(i-SITE and no-show) = 0.65 × 0.02 = 0.013
  3. P(no-show) = 0.021 + 0.013 = 0.034
  4. P(onlineno-show) = 0.0210.034 = 0.6176
  5. RR = 0.060.02 = 3online three times as likely to no-show
  6. 61.8% of no-shows are online although 65% of bookings are i-SITE: the higher risk outweighs the smaller share
AS 91586

Question 4 · Normal distribution

a
Achieved

The crossing time of a passenger ferry from downtown Auckland to Waiheke Island is modelled by a normal distribution with mean 42 minutes and standard deviation 3.5 minutes. Use this model to estimate the probability that a crossing takes more than 48 minutes.

Hint

Let X be the crossing time. Find P(X > 48) with the normal distribution, μ = 42 and σ = 3.5.

Answer

P(X > 48) = 0.0432

Step by step
  1. Say what is random first: X = the time a crossing takes, in minutes.
  2. The model is normal with μ = 42 and σ = 3.5, so X ~ N(42, 3.5²).
  3. 48 minutes is above the mean, so we want the right tail: P(X > 48).
  4. Standardise: z = 48 − 423.5 = 1.714. So 48 minutes is about 1.7 standard deviations above the mean.
  5. Calculator, normal cdf from 48 to a very large number with μ = 42, σ = 3.5: 0.0432.
  6. Check it is sensible: about 4% of crossings take more than 48 minutes. That is small, which fits a value well above the mean.
Full working
  1. X ~ N(42, 3.5²)X = crossing time in minutes
  2. z = 48 − 423.5 = 1.714
  3. P(X > 48) = P(Z > 1.714)right tail
  4. P(X > 48) = 0.0432
AS 91586

Question 5 · Binomial distribution

a
Achieved

At a kiwifruit packhouse in Te Puke, 4% of kiwifruit are rejected for skin blemishes. A tray holds 30 kiwifruit.

Use a probability distribution model to estimate the probability that a tray has at most 2 rejected kiwifruit. State the name and parameters of the distribution as part of your answer.

x012345
P(X = x)0.080.220.30k0.120.06
Hint

A fixed number of fruit (30), each rejected or not, with the same chance (0.04): binomial.

Answer

X = number of rejected kiwifruit in a tray, X ~ Bin(30, 0.04). P(X ≤ 2) = 0.8831.

Step by step
  1. Define X = the number of rejected kiwifruit in a tray of 30.
  2. There is a fixed number of trials (30 fruit), two outcomes (rejected or not) and the same probability for each fruit (0.04).
  3. So X is binomial: X ~ Bin(30, 0.04), assuming fruit are rejected independently.
  4. At most 2 means 0, 1 or 2: P(X ≤ 2) = P(X = 0) + P(X = 1) + P(X = 2).
  5. These are 0.2939 + 0.3673 + 0.2219 = 0.8831.
  6. Calculator, binomial cdf with n = 30, p = 0.04, up to x = 2: 0.8831.
  7. Check: the mean is 30 × 0.04 = 1.2 rejects, so at most 2 should be very likely. 0.88 fits.
Full working
  1. X ~ Bin(30, 0.04)X = rejected fruit in a tray of 30
  2. P(X ≤ 2) = P(X = 0) + P(X = 1) + P(X = 2)
  3. = 0.2939 + 0.3673 + 0.2219
  4. P(X ≤ 2) = 0.8831
AS 91586

Question 6 · Poisson distribution

c
Merit

The packhouse's forklifts break down at an average rate of 0.6 breakdowns per week during the harvest.

(i) Use a Poisson distribution to find the probability of at least 2 breakdowns in a 4-week period.

(ii) Describe two conditions needed for the Poisson model in this context, and discuss whether one of them is likely to hold.

x012345
P(X = x)0.080.220.30k0.120.06
Hint

Scale the rate to 4 weeks first. At least 2 is 1 − P(X = 0) − P(X = 1).

Answer

(i) X ~ Po(2.4); P(X ≥ 2) = 0.6916. (ii) Breakdowns happen independently of each other, and at a constant average rate. A constant rate is doubtful: forklifts work harder in peak weeks and wear out, so breakdowns are likely to be more frequent at the height of the harvest.

Step by step
  1. (i) Define X = the number of forklift breakdowns in a 4-week period.
  2. The rate is 0.6 per week, so over 4 weeks λ = 0.6 × 4 = 2.4. So X ~ Po(2.4).
  3. At least 2 is everything except 0 and 1: P(X ≥ 2) = 1 − P(X = 0) − P(X = 1).
  4. P(X = 0) = e^(−2.4) = 0.0907. P(X = 1) = 2.4 × e^(−2.4) = 0.2177.
  5. P(X ≥ 2) = 1 − 0.0907 − 0.2177 = 0.6916.
  6. (ii) Condition 1, independence: one breakdown does not make another more or less likely.
  7. Condition 2, constant rate: breakdowns happen at the same average rate (0.6 a week) throughout the 4 weeks.
  8. Other conditions: breakdowns happen one at a time, never two at exactly the same moment, and at random.
  9. Discussion: the constant rate is doubtful. At the peak of the harvest the forklifts run for longer shifts with heavier loads, so they are more likely to break down then than early in the season.
  10. Independence may also fail: if a mechanic does a rushed repair, the same forklift may break down again soon.
Full working
  1. λ = 0.6 × 4 = 2.4scale to 4 weeks
  2. X ~ Po(2.4)X = breakdowns in 4 weeks
  3. P(X ≥ 2) = 1 − 0.0907 − 0.2177
  4. P(X ≥ 2) = 0.6916
  5. Conditions: independent breakdowns, constant rate; constant rate doubtful in peak harvest
AS 91586

Question 7 · Triangular distribution

d
Excellence

The station plans a promotion: if a customer waits longer than t minutes, their WOF is free. The manager wants only 5% of customers to get a free WOF.

(i) Use the triangular model with a = 5, c = 15 and b = 50 to find t, to 1 decimal place.

(ii) Use the table to estimate the proportion of customers who would actually wait longer than this t. Explain why it differs from 5%.

Waiting time (minutes)Number of customers
5 to under 1014
10 to under 1533
15 to under 2030
20 to under 2524
25 to under 3017
30 to under 3512
35 to under 408
40 to under 455
45 to under 503
50 to under 552
55 to under 601
60 to under 651
Hint

In the right tail, P(X > t) = (b − t)²(b − a)(b − c). Set that equal to 0.05 and solve for t.

Answer

(i) t = 41.1 minutes. (ii) About 11 of 150 customers, roughly 7%, waited longer than 41.1 minutes. The model has no waits past 50, but the data has a long right tail, so the model underestimates the proportion.

Step by step
  1. (i) t will be in the right tail, past the peak at 15. The right-tail area formula is (b − t)²(b − a)(b − c).
  2. (50 − t)²45 × 35 = 0.05, so (50 − t)² = 0.05 × 1575 = 78.75.
  3. 50 − t = √78.75 = 8.874, so t = 41.1 minutes.
  4. (ii) From the table, 3 + 2 + 1 + 1 = 7 customers waited 45 minutes or more.
  5. In the 40 to 45 class there are 5 customers. 41.1 to 45 is about 3.9 of those 5 minutes, so assume about 5 × 3.95 ≈ 3.9 of them waited more than 41.1 minutes.
  6. That gives about 7 + 3.9 ≈ 10.9 customers, and 10.9150 ≈ 0.072, roughly 7%.
  7. So the real proportion is higher than 5%. The b = 50 model cuts off the long tail: it says no one waits past 50, but 4 customers did.
  8. The model also fits the 30 minute tail a little high (part (c)), but the cut-off at 50 matters more this far out, so the free WOFs are underestimated.
Full working
  1. (50 − t)²45 × 35 = 0.05right-tail area
  2. (50 − t)² = 78.75, so t = 50 − 8.874 = 41.1
  3. data: 7 + 5 × 3.95 ≈ 10.9 customersspread evenly within 40 to 45
  4. 10.9150 ≈ 0.072
  5. t = 41.1 minutes; about 7% of customers in the data would get a free WOF, more than 5%, because the model leaves out waits over 50

Past papers

AS 91585

AS 91586

NCEA Level 3 Statistics · AS 91585 past papers · AS 91586 past papers