Choosing a distribution: 7 exam questions solved step by step
What this lesson covers
- Each distribution has conditions, and the conditions decide the model, not the number it produces.
- Name the distribution and its parameters every time, or the answer cannot earn a grade.
7 questions, one routine
- 1. Define X in words, with units.
- 2. Name the model and its parameters.
- 3. State the conditions in context.
- 4. Calculate, round, say it.
Question 1 · Achieved, in context
- Each kōwhai seed germinates with
- probability 0.85. 12 seeds are sown.
- Find P(exactly 10 germinate).
Q1: binomial
- Count out of a fixed n.
- Conditions, then calculate.
- X = seeds that germinate of 12
- X ~ Bin(12, 0.85)binomial
- fixed n: 12 seedsgerminate or not
- p = 0.85 for every seedconstant p
- seeds germinate independently
- P(X = 10) = 0.292358binomial
- = 0.29244 d.p.
- about a 29% chance
Question 2 · Achieved
- Bags of flour labelled 1 kg have masses
- with mean 1.02 kg and sd 0.015 kg,
- bell-shaped about the mean. What
- proportion of bags are under 1 kg?
Q2: normal
- A measurement: continuous.
- Symmetric: normal.
- X = mass of a bag, in kg
- X ~ N(μ = 1.02, σ = 0.015)bell-shaped, continuous
- P(X < 1)
- z = (1 − 1.02) ÷ 0.015
- = −1.3333below the mean
- P(X < 1) = 0.091211
- = 0.09124 d.p.
- about 9% of bags are under 1 kg
Question 3 · Merit
- Flaws in a roll of fabric occur at an
- average rate of 1.5 per metre.
- Find P(at least one flaw in a 2 m length).
- Careful: per metre, but 2 m.
Q3: Poisson
- Count in an interval.
- Scale λ to that interval.
- X = flaws in a 2 m length
- flaws occur independently
- at a constant average rate
- X ~ Po(1.5)that is for 1 m
- λ = 1.5 × 2 = 3rate for 2 m
- X ~ Po(3)
- P(X ≥ 1) = 1 − P(X = 0)
- = 1 − 0.049787
- = 0.950213 ≈ 0.95024 d.p.
Question 4 · Merit
- A 2 m rope is equally likely to break
- at any point along its length. Find
- P(the shorter piece is under 0.5 m).
Q4: uniform
- Equally likely: flat.
- Either end can be short.
- X = break point, m from one end
- X uniform from 0 to 2equally likely
- height = 1 ÷ 2 = 0.5total area 1
- shorter < 0.5: X < 0.5 or X > 1.5
- P(X < 0.5) = 0.5 × 0.5 = 0.25
- P(X > 1.5) = 0.5 × 0.5 = 0.25
- total = 0.25 + 0.25 = 0.5
- a 50% chance
Question 5 · Merit, in context
- A drive to Auckland Airport takes at
- least 25 min, most often 35 min, and
- at most 60 min. Choose a model and
- find P(the drive takes over 50 min).
Q5: triangular
- Min, mode, max only.
- The tail is a triangle.
- X = drive time, in minutes
- triangular: 25, 35, 60min, mode, max
- long tail to 60: skewedso not normal
- peak height = 2 ÷ 35 = 2/35
- height at 50 = 10/25 × 2/35similar triangles
- = 4/175
- P(X > 50) = ½ × 10 × 4/175triangle area
- = 4/35 = 0.11434 d.p.
- about 11% of drives over 50 min
Question 6 · Excellence
- A region feels an average of 2
- earthquakes a month. Find P(5 or more
- in a month). Last month there were 9,
- after one large quake. Judge the model.
Q6: the Poisson answer
- A count per month.
- Use the complement.
- X = quakes felt in a month
- X ~ Po(2)rate 2 per month
- P(X ≥ 5) = 1 − P(X ≤ 4)
- = 1 − 0.947347
- = 0.052653 ≈ 0.05274 d.p.
Q6: do the conditions hold?
- Check each condition.
- In this context.
- P(X ≥ 9) = 0.000237if Po(2) holds
- aftershocks follow a big quake
- independentquakes trigger quakes
- constant raterate jumps after one
- Po(2) did not fit last month
- Po(2) suits quiet months only
Question 7 · Excellence
- A box holds 20 phones, 4 faulty.
- 5 are picked without replacement.
- Malia uses Bin(5, 0.2) for the faulty
- count. Judge it; find P(none faulty).
Q7: is it binomial?
- Check every condition.
- Does p stay the same?
- X = faulty phones of the 5
- fixed n = 5, faulty or not
- 1st pick: p = 4/20 = 0.2
- 2nd pick: 4/19 or 3/19no replacement
- p is not constant
- picks are not independent
- X ~ Bin(5, 0.2)conditions fail
Q7: the right probability
- Multiply pick by pick.
- Compare with binomial.
- P(X = 0) = 16/20 × 15/19 × 14/18
- × 13/17 × 12/16
- = 91/323 = 0.28174 d.p.
- Bin: 0.8⁵ = 0.3277too high
- box of 2000: 0.3273p barely changes
- then Bin(5, 0.2) is fair
- for this box: P(X = 0) = 0.2817
The method that solved all seven
- Define X, name the model, state the conditions in context, then calculate.
| Step | How |
|---|---|
| Define X | in words, with units |
| Name it | model and parameters |
| Conditions | in the context |
| Poisson | scale λ to the interval |
| Calculate | statement, result, round |
| Judge | which condition could fail |
More in AS 91586
Choosing a distribution, and naming it every time7 min
Discrete random variables: mean and standard deviation6 min
Binomial and Poisson: at least, at most, and the rate7 min
The normal distribution: forwards, backwards and conditional7 min
Uniform and triangular distributions, and judging a model7 min
Choosing a distribution: 7 exam questions solved step by step10 min
Discrete random variables: 7 exam questions solved step by step11 min
Binomial and Poisson: 7 exam questions solved step by step10 min
Normal distribution: 7 exam questions solved step by step10 min
Uniform and triangular: 7 exam questions solved step by step10 minIs your child on track?
Take the free placement test